Reply to Bishop Wester,
I just finished reading an article about you and a speech you
made in the Dec. 20, 2007, edition of The Spectrum and Daily News -
again.
As a Catholic, I was very disturbed when I read your comments
about illegal aliens. In the article, you are quoted as saying that
Joseph and Mary were immigrants. This is stretching the truth at the
very least.
When I read the Bible, I learned that Joseph and Mary went to
Bethlehem to participate in a census. That was not immigration.
After being warned by an Angel, they fled to Egypt to avoid the
murder of their son, Jesus. That wasn't immigration, either. Unless
you, personally, or someone in the church has rewritten the New
Testament without my knowledge, I don't believe the words of Mathew,
Mark, Luke and John have changed.
I don't know how you define words, but to immigrate is defined as
a permanent move to another country. Joseph and Mary stayed in Egypt
for only a short time and returned to their home to stay and raise
their children. Including Jesus.
To compare Joseph, Mary and Jesus with the aliens who
deliberately commit an illegal act to enter our country is specious,
and demeaning to the Saints and Jesus. They broke no laws and only
fled to save the life of their son. They did not stay illegally in
Egypt.
Now, I am all for compassion for the weak, infirm, elderly, poor
and otherwise beleaguered folks among us. However, I have no
sympathy for lawbreakers who compound their sin every day they stay
here.
May I suggest that the activism of the church would be better
served by decrying the oppression the illegals suffer in their own
country. I mean do it there, not here. It is not the fault of the
citizens, or the government of the United States, that these
unfortunate people are oppressed and impoverished in the countries
of their origin. Nor, is it our responsibility to condone illegal
acts or to encourage them.
On another note, why don't these people stay in their countries
and fight for change? Our antecedents did it here. I would be happy
to support people fighting for justice, freedom and human rights in
their own countries.
Finally, the people of the United States simply cannot afford to
accept 20 million and more illegal aliens and their huge drain on
our economy. I am an older, disabled man, and maybe it's a sin, but
I resent the fact that I suffer in many ways because my government
and other entities are more focused on aid to illegals than they are
to myself and millions of other natural born and naturalized
citizens.
Garey L. Bearden is a resident of Milford. He is a member of The
Spectrum & Daily News Writers Group.